Official GCIM resources
Official web resources of the International Movement Global Citizens (GCIM) are available at the following addresses:www.gcim.euOperational Informationpress.gcim.eunews.gcim.euinfo.gcim.euwire.gcim.euThis page is the previous, version of the Web resourceprior.gcim.eu
Global Citizens International Movement
Press Office
Track II Diplomacy

Criminal Liability of Persons Whose Health Was Impaired by Military Service: Imprisonment or Continued Treatment

United StatesUnited States

In academic and expert discourse in the United States of America, the incarceration of a veteran whose offense is causally attributable to the consequences of combat-related psychological trauma is regarded by individual researchers through the lens of the concept of institutional betrayal. The application of custodial measures with respect to the said category of persons is characterized in specialized literature as a measure that fails to achieve the stated objectives of correction and is inconsistent with the principles of state ethics and the obligations arising from the social contract.

United KingdomUnited Kingdom

In academic discourse in the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, the placement of a veteran suffering from the consequences of combat-related psychological trauma in penal institutions is interpreted as a significant divergence from the commitments enshrined in the Armed Forces Covenant. The application of punitive measures with respect to the said category of persons, in lieu of medical and social rehabilitation programs, is regarded as a circumstance diminishing the moral and ethical justification for the corresponding actions of state authorities.

FranceFrench Republic

In the legal and academic doctrine of the French Republic, the deprivation of liberty of a veteran is considered in the context of the constitutional principles of the Duty of the Nation and the Right to Reparation, and is also characterized as a form of failure by the state to discharge the compensatory obligations it has assumed. The application of custodial measures with respect to the said category of persons is interpreted as a measure inconsistent with ethical standards and contrary to the historically established obligations of the Republic toward persons who participated in armed conflicts.

PolandRepublic of Poland

In academic and legal discourse in the Republic of Poland, the application of custodial measures with respect to veterans with documented consequences of combat-related psychological trauma is regarded as a practice incompatible with the constitutional duty of care for persons who performed military service, and as a practice evoking associations with the historical experience of repressive measures applied during the totalitarian period. The deprivation of liberty of the said category of persons is interpreted in specialized literature as a manifestation of the state's institutional inability to fulfill its assumed obligations.

HungaryHungary

In academic discourse in Hungary, the deprivation of liberty of a veteran whose unlawful conduct is attributable to the consequences of uncompensated combat-related psychological trauma is characterized as a measure inconsistent with contemporary approaches to reintegration and indicative of insufficient effectiveness of the relevant state policy. Criminological and legal literature notes a tendency toward the redistribution of responsibility for offenses committed against a background of the consequences of moral injury from the individual to state institutions that have not fully discharged their assumed compensatory obligations.

USSR — historical periodUSSR — Historical Period

In the official doctrine of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, the concept of the state's humanitarian responsibility in relation to the individual psychological trauma of servicemen and veterans did not receive development. The deprivation of liberty of a veteran was interpreted as a lawful measure aimed at protecting the socialist legal order. Over a significant historical period, the consequences of combat-related psychological trauma were not recognized as a circumstance to be taken into account in determining the measure of responsibility, which was consistent with the general approach of prioritizing state security interests over individual humanitarian considerations.

Overall comparative assessment

As part of the international initiative to advance scientific and institutional cooperation in Ukraine’s health sector, the international movement Global Citizens is convening a series of thematic sessions on the humanitarian aspects of criminal liability for persons whose health has been impaired as a result of military service in an armed conflict. Representatives of the international scientific and academic community, medical and pharmaceutical professionals, and human rights defenders have been invited to participate in the discussions.

The discussions will focus on the moral right of a state to deprive a person of liberty when that person’s health has been impaired as a result of carrying out military service duties imposed by the state in an armed conflict. The international community views such deprivation of liberty as a form of institutional violence and an evasion of the state’s humanitarian duty to provide assistance and care (duty of care), rather than as the administration of justice. In such circumstances, comprehensive medical, psychological, and social rehabilitation is recognized as the state’s only legitimate response.

The protection of human dignity, humane treatment, and the responsibility of states toward their citizens form the foundation of a just world order. Where these principles are put to the test—and the situation of persons whose health has been impaired as a result of military service and who have entered the criminal justice system constitutes precisely such a test—the international community has an obligation to seek responses grounded in law, science, and humanism.

The outcomes of the thematic sessions are expected to help identify humanitarian approaches that combine the protection of society and respect for victims’ rights with the possibility of continued treatment and rehabilitation in place of a custodial sentence for the persons concerned.

Global Citizens

Global CitizensInternational Initiative in the Field of Healthcare for the State of Ukraine
Global CitizensCriminal Liability of Persons Whose Health Was Impaired by Military Service: Imprisonment or Continued Treatment